Peer Review Process
Mathews Open Access Journals follows double blind peer review process. In this we do not reveal author names, affiliations to the reviewer and vice versa. We adhere to the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), code of conduct, and best practice guidelines (http://publicationethics.org). We strive to ensure that the peer review is fair, unbiased and timely. Decisions to accept or reject a manuscript for publication in the journal are based on the manuscript’s importance, originality, clarity, and the study’s validity and its relevance to remit of the journal. The process also involves strictly no plagiarism or fabrication of the data and parallel submissions.
Responsibilities
Being a reviewer you are accountable to take the responsibility of maintaining confidentiality of ideas that have been presented in the papers assigned to review. Focus your evaluation on merits and demerits of the article; assess the correctness, accuracy, clarity, and innovation of the research. Never reveal the assigned paper's results or videos/images or any of the supplementary material to non-reviewers.
The reviewers are given ample time for the review and submission of comments to the editorial office. Reviewers’ evaluations play a major role in our decision as to whether to accept a manuscript for publication.
Ethical Issues
Published : 06th June 2025
Authors : Smilja Tudzarova-Gjorgova*, Ana Selchanec, Gloria Gjorgova, Nina Karadjinova, Ljuben Angelovski
Citation : Tudzarova-Gjorgova S, et al. (2025). Surgical Success in Facial Paralysis: A Combined Surgical Approach with Eyelid Gold Weight Implant and Tensor Fascia Lata Sling. Mathews J Case Rep. 10(3):208.
Published : 24th May 2025
Authors : Z Kabala1,*, S El Jay1, M Belhouari1, M Bourhafour1, S Sahraoui1
Citation : Kabala Z, et al. (2025). Alveolar Vaginal Rhabdomyosarcoma in an Adult: A Rare Case Report and Comprehensive Literature Review. Mathews J Case Rep. 10(3):207.
Published : 21st May 2025
Authors : Mamane Taïbou Tanimoune*, Bjane Oussama, Mouad El Badre, Nachid Abdallah, Pr Kbirou A, Pr Moataz A, Pr Debbagh A, Pr Dakir M, Pr Aboutaeib R
Citation : Tanimoune MT, et al. (2025). Squamous Cell Carcinoma of the Penis on Buschke-Lowenstein Tumor Recurring After Emasculation: A Case Report. Mathews J Case Rep. 10(3):206.
Published : 11th April 2025
Authors : Luisetto Mauro1,*, Mashori GR2, Cabianca L3, Hamid AG4, Latyshev Ole Yurevich5
Citation : Luisetto M, et al. (2025). A Chronic Prostatitis Case Report with Frequent Re-Acutization: Factors Involved and Examples of Remedy. Mathews J Case Rep. 10(3):205.
Published : 10th April 2025
Authors : Safwate Reda*, Safieddine Mehdi, Nachid Abdellah, Ait Mahanna Hamza, Daghdagh Yassine, Kbirou Adil, Moataz Amine, Dakir Mohamed, Debbagh Adil, Aboutaieb Rachid
Citation : Reda S, et al. (2025). Bone Metastases of Urothelial Carcinoma. Mathews J Case Rep. 10(2):204.
Published : 04th April 2025
Authors : Stefan Peters1,*, Axel von Werder2, Jörg Werhahn3
Citation : Peters S, et al. (2025). An Adolescent Asymtomatic Case with Uhl Anomaly. Mathews J Case Rep. 10(2):202.