Peer Review Process
Mathews Open Access Journals follows double blind peer review process. In this we do not reveal author names, affiliations to the reviewer and vice versa. We adhere to the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), code of conduct, and best practice guidelines (http://publicationethics.org). We strive to ensure that the peer review is fair, unbiased and timely. Decisions to accept or reject a manuscript for publication in the journal are based on the manuscript’s importance, originality, clarity, and the study’s validity and its relevance to remit of the journal. The process also involves strictly no plagiarism or fabrication of the data and parallel submissions.
Responsibilities
Being a reviewer you are accountable to take the responsibility of maintaining confidentiality of ideas that have been presented in the papers assigned to review. Focus your evaluation on merits and demerits of the article; assess the correctness, accuracy, clarity, and innovation of the research. Never reveal the assigned paper's results or videos/images or any of the supplementary material to non-reviewers.
The reviewers are given ample time for the review and submission of comments to the editorial office. Reviewers’ evaluations play a major role in our decision as to whether to accept a manuscript for publication.
Ethical Issues
Published : 04th September 2023
Authors : Redha Lakehal1,*, Jalaleddinne Omar Bouhidel2, Soumaya Bendjaballah1, Khaled Khacha3,Abdelmalek Bouzid3, Radouane Boukarroucha1
Citation : Lakehal R, et al. (2023). Hemorrhagic Shock After Rupture of an Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm in a Woman with No Medical History: A Case Report. Mathews J Surg. 6(3):22.
Published : 01st August 2023
Authors : Nabeel Almadwahi1, Mohammed S. Najran2, Abdulhafeedh Al-Habeet3,*, Saleh A. Alammari4, Mohamed Alshujaa2, Fahd Ali Alfahd2, Ali A. Barat2, Aref A. Al-Hashedi2, Sallam Al-Alhanash2, Emad Halbob2, Abeer Shaia’a Naji Sa’adan2, Asmaa Ali Aljorob5
Citation : Almadwahi N, et al. (2023). Surgical Management of Carotid Body Tumors: A Triple Center Retrospective Study in Sana’a City, Yemen. Mathews J Surg. 6(3):21.
Published : 25th July 2023
Authors : Pankaj Goyal1,*, Kishan Kumawat2 GN Gupta3 Nidhi P Chanchlani4
Citation : Goyal P, et al. (2023). Epidermoid Cyst of Suprasternal Region in an Adolescent: A Rare Case Report. Mathews J Surg. 6(3):20.
Published : 18th May 2023
Authors : Shaikh Mohd Shaad1, Pathrikar Prathamesh1, Desai Shivani1, Sheth Neil1, Chatterjee Sanjay2,*
Citation : Shaad SM, et al. (2023). Curious Case of Obstructive Jaundice: A Case Report. Mathews J Surg. 6(2):19.
Published : 26th April 2023
Authors : Nizar Cherni1, Abdallah Chaachou1, Wael Ferjaoui2,*, Samir Ghozzi1, Mohamed Dridi1
Citation : Ferjaoui W, et al. (2023). Impact of Varicocele Cure on Spermogram Parameters and Fertility. Mathews J Surg. 6(1):18.
Published : 25th January 2023
Authors : Keshavi Mehta1, Prathamesh Pathrikar1, Mohd Shaad Shaikh1, Sanjay Chatterjee2,3,*
Citation : Mehta K, et al. (2023). A Curious Case of Drain Going Intraluminal. Mathews J Surg. 6(1):17.